IslandVibesIOP.com 12 When I returned to Isle of Palms, I moved into my parents’ vacation house, a modest 900-square-foot brick ranch. Living there helped me appreciate the island as it was then. Our neighborhoods were filled with smaller ranch homes, many built by J.C. Long. Open yards and familiar faces defined streets where families put down roots. When I eventually bought a house of my own, it turned out to be another J.C. Long home. Over time, I watched many of those houses disappear, replaced by homes three or four times their size. Modernization matters, but age alone doesn’t make a house obsolete. WHEN THE RULES WORKED AGAINST RENOVATION After purchasing our own J.C. Long home, I recognized how much the city’s regulations could hold back residents who wanted to improve and preserve these older houses. We wanted to renovate and expand our home while keeping its original character. But this wasn’t just our problem. Many island homeowners faced restrictions that made improving a perfectly good house expensive or impractical. Tearing it down and starting over could seem like the easier choice. At the heart of the issue was the city’s five-year cumulative tracking requirement associated with the substantial improvement rule, commonly called the 50% rule. Under floodplain regulations, when Razed or Saved? Giving Isle of Palms’ older homes a second chance By Ryan Buckhannon qualifying improvements reach 50% of a structure’s market value, the building can be required to meet applicable flood standards. That calculation excludes the land, even when the lot is worth far more than the house. For many older ranch homes, even a single renovation would put homeowners over the 50% cap, triggering costly requirements to bring the entire house into compliance with current flood standards. And if that renovation stayed below the threshold, any additional improvements over the next five years would count toward the same limit. Homeowners were left with an impossible choice: leave their aging homes as they were or pay to bring the entire structure into compliance. When improving the house was no longer financially practical, tearing it down and starting over often became the only realistic option. TAKING THE ISSUE TO CITY COUNCIL The more I examined the rules, the more I questioned why Isle of Palms needed a five-year requirement on top of existing floodplain standards. I wasn’t trying to eliminate FEMA’s safety protections. We live on a barrier island, and those protections matter. I wanted to remove unnecessary local restrictions that discouraged preservation. What began with our own home became a larger effort to help residents facing similar obstacles. As a city council member, I took it upon myself to find an answer. I worked with Planning Commission members and city staff, asking questions, reviewing regulations and exploring ways to give homeowners more flexibility while maintaining flood safety. In 2018, the Planning Commission recommended reducing the tracking period from five years to one. That was progress, but I didn’t think it went far enough. If we could satisfy applicable flood requirements without this extra cumulative restriction, why keep it at all? At the March 27, 2018, city council meeting, I proposed eliminating the local tracking period. Some worried owners might split larger projects to avoid the threshold. I understood the concern but also saw how keeping the rule could cost us more older homes. I moved to eliminate the five-year tracking requirement. It passed by a 5-4 vote, and the ordinance was adopted the following month. For me, it wasn’t simply about changing an ordinance. I wanted to preserve the house we already had and allow other homeowners to do the same. A CHANGE THAT MADE A DIFFERENCE Years later, I asked Douglas Kerr, the city’s building and zoning director at the time and now city administrator, whether the change had helped save older homes. He replied: “From my perspective, this change absolutely had an impact and resulted in many older homes being saved and remodeled instead of being torn down.” His firsthand assessment meant a great deal to me. By removing the additional five-year tracking period, we gave residents more flexibility to make improvements without having separate projects automatically added together over five years. The underlying flood safety requirements remained in place. That was the result I had hoped for: more opportunities to give existing homes another life. MORE THAN JUST AN OLD HOUSE These ranch homes are part of Isle of Palms history. Families started here, children grew up and neighbors formed lasting connections. Today, a modest ranch might be replaced by a 3,500-square-foot or larger home. New construction has its place, and not every older house can be saved. But larger buildings, additional paving and pools can also affect drainage and change the character of established neighborhoods. Preservation isn’t about stopping progress. It’s about keeping renovation a realistic option. WHAT KIND OF ISLAND ARE WE LEAVING BEHIND? I still think about the little brick ranch I lived in and the J.C. Long house we later purchased. Neither needed to be grand to be meaningful. They helped me understand what made this island special. When I worked to eliminate the five-year rule, my goal was simple: give homeowners the freedom to improve, modernize and expand their homes without unnecessary government red tape and burdensome local regulations. We removed that obstacle while still meeting flood safety standards. When we ask whether an older island home will be razed or saved, we’re talking about more than bricks and lumber. We’re talking about the character of our neighborhoods and what we leave for the next generation. I wasn’t trying to replace the house we already had. I was trying to find a way to save it. BEFORE AFTER COMMUNITY
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjcyNTM1